Your design team spends various sprints working on a large project for a prominent client, and the most important day arrives — the big unveiling. Presenting the creative work is exciting and fun (and yes, a bit anxiety-inducing). But what follows is actually the most crucial part: the client’s feedback. How do you get productive design feedback that make the work better?
Creative feedback is the one milestone every design project has in common and a natural part of the process. It both benefits the project and helps your team grow.
Unless you’re in the same field (e.g. designers working with other designers), many people outside the industry have a hard time articulating their thoughts. It can be difficult for clients and collaborators to focus their feedback beyond ‘I like it or ‘I don’t like it.’ The responsibility falls on your team to ask the right questions, and get better design feedback so you can move the work forward.
So how do you prevent the dreaded “I’ll know it when I see it,” and move past surface-level comments? Whether you’re working on UX design, landing pages, website design or any visual work, here’s an actionable list to get better creative feedback from your client. Better feedback leads to a higher quality result and, hopefully, more projects in the future.
What is the decision hierarchy?
While a client may be one company, your client team actually includes several stakeholders within that organization. There’s likely a pecking order. Receiving timely feedback from several stakeholders, often in different roles, can easily lead to a “too many cooks in the kitchen” situation. It can also delay the project more than you think.
It’s essential to assign a single owner on the client side, often a project manager, to make sure all feedback filters through this person and they consult every needed stakeholder.
Wayne Pelletier from Resonant Pixel, a small agency owner with 20+ years of experience in brand strategy and client management, shares that giving good feedback is a very individual process. “I now know, after years of doing this, what and how to share.”
With clients that require multiple revisions, don’t just send something off without context, Pelletier advises. He suggests having a meaningful conversation on how you strategically delivered each piece of content, and even including some commentary of your own explaining the “why.” Punchlist is an excellent tool for this, he says, as it consolidates all comments in one place. It also records changes for those that missed a meeting, and keeps a “paper trail” of decision history.
In the end, knowing the owner of the project and the decision hierarchy within the client’s company will deliver those requested changes more effectively and keep the project moving.
Encourage a problem vs. solution perspective
When the client needs a change, they may come to you with a suggested solution. Listen to that feedback and follow it by asking what the initial problem is. Encourage the client to tell you about the problem they see, and your design team can quickly create solutions versus relying solely on the client’s feedback. This allows the trust to grow within your relationship and use your agency’s expertise more effectively — while giving them what they want.
You don’t need a prescription for exactly what to do. You may just need to know the creative challenge, and the constraint — then you can do what you do best.
Keep asking why
Why? Why? Why? That is the question.
While listening is a number one priority during client meetings, it’s also important to understand the why behind the client’s feedback. Before moving to the next item, ask why. Get clarification if needed on the intention behind a specific piece of feedback. Often the issue is easy to resolve — or may not even need to be addressed.
In some cases, if you provide data to support your design decisions, it can quickly resolve that feedback without further changes. Some stakeholders are more data-driven than design-driven. They want to see how this will work within their strategy. For example, how a site will perform with a specific target audience and how these design elements play into that.
Keep asking why and follow up, if needed, with some performance, conversion, or UX data to corroborate your decisions.
If you really want to understand a client’s rationale behind their comments, try the 5 whys framework. This will get you to the emotional root cause, and help you deliver their desired outcome with a creative solution of your own.
Consolidate design feedback — both ways
Consolidating design feedback works both ways when working with clients. After the initial delivery, get the team together and go over it in detail when responding to the client’s points.
“Punchlist allows me to have a productive conversation about the granular pieces of the creative and move past the “do you like it” phase,” says Pelletier.
Consolidating all client design feedback before a call can help get more done during a phone call. And the ability to quickly share a Punchlist URL in a Google Calendar invite makes it easy for the client to access.
Pelletier likes to add comments and mark them up in Punchlist before going over everything on a call with the client. “Punchlist is a game-changer because you can have all that feedback in one place and have a conversation about it. I can screen-share and show those things line by line,” he says.
They can add follow-up replies following the call after consulting stakeholders. No app download nor installation necessary.
Creative teams and clients alike can even record a page overview video to pre-frame their feedback and explain the rationale or theme behind it.
Beware of scope creep
They say that there’s such a thing as too much feedback. It’s true.
Scope creep is every client’s (and agency’s) nemesis, and that’s why it’s important to have a clear project owner. Too much feedback that it’s hard to filter through or even rogue emails with tangent ideas can make a project quickly stop in its tracks.
At one point, the client needs to pick a path forward to get the project across the finish line. Before the kick-off meeting, scale back the options intentionally before presenting them to the client.
Non-designers can quickly get overwhelmed with too many options. When you present solutions, you pick up to three and give the pros of each one strategically. Keep the meeting on a good path by clearly stating the options, explaining completed feedback, and action items before moving forward.
The client needs to understand why these are the best options and how to make an informed decision. If required, repeat the project’s original thesis and the options, so they see the whole picture.
Lastly, be mindful of going too many rounds of revisions. Sometimes a freelancer or small studio starting out will offer “unlimited revisions” on creative work. Avoid this trap. Decide early on (and put it in your client contract) how many rounds of feedback you’ll accommodate.
Consolidate comments into specific rounds, and keep your projects within scope to deliver on time.
Keep the feedback loop open
Client feedback is the one constant every agency, studio or freelancer has to deal with. Your design feedback process should be clear, concise, and straightforward for all parties but easy to replicate across projects. It shouldn’t be yet another chore, but a pleasant experience for both sides of the table.
With Punchlist, you can empower your clients to leave detailed feedback and answer your questions all in one place. No more long afternoon meetings, endless email threads, or getting feedback on the wrong version of the file. Punchlist provides an easy-to-copy URL to share with the client and to keep all changes and questions in one spot.
Delight your client and make your design team’s life easier.
Follow these tips to get better design feedback from your client, and help them help you create better work.
New Feature: Search Your Entire Punchlist WorkspaceAugust 30, 2022
We’re thrilled to unveil a completely rebuilt feature this week to all Punchlist users: Search! Now, you can search through your entire Punchlist Workspace for specific feedback, projects and pages at lightning speed. Your Digital Paper Trail No more “he said, she said” or combing through endless emails threads trying to dig up what was [...]
What's It Like To Build In Webflow? [Video Series]July 20, 2022
What’s it like to build in Webflow? Our friends at Edgar Allan invited us to their “EA Live” series to show you the ropes. In this video walkthrough, their team does a live design & build of the Punchlist.com homepage. Webflow is an online visual editor platform allowing users to create websites without having to [...]
How to Write a Creative Brief That Inspires Your TeamJune 29, 2022
Learning how to write a creative brief might sound tedious, but it’s one of the most important aspects of any creative endeavor. To understand the relationship between a creative brief and finished project, let’s talk structural engineering for a moment. We’re all familiar with Italy’s Tower of Pisa. Did you know that a faulty foundation [...]
Dealing with Difficult Feedback: The Creative's ToolkitMay 20, 2022
Creative teams often have a familial vibe. This is unsurprising, as we often spend more time working together than we do with our loved ones. We toil together, learn together, grow together, and even eat dinner together as we dedicate long hours to major projects, pitches and launches. This family dynamic really manifests itself when [...]
Handling an Unresponsive Client the Right Way (with Email Templates)April 27, 2022
Nothing derails a project quite like hearing crickets from unresponsive clients. We’ve all been there before. You have the kickoff meeting, get all your ducks in a row, send over the first draft for feedback, and…nothing. After what feels like a month-long game of “Where’s Waldo?”, your client finally gets back to you with approval, [...]
How to Avoid Micromanaging Your Creatives Into the GroundApril 22, 2022
Those in creative leadership must understand the dangers of micromanaging if their teams are to thrive. Creativity is delicate. Designers, writers and developers will often come up with a far better solution if given the right challenge to solve or goal to achieve, versus telling them “Do it this exact way.” That’s why we’ve prepared [...]
How to Get Clients Out of the Comfort Zone (and into New Tools & Processes)April 13, 2022
While agencies tend to be early adopters of the latest tools and tech, it’s not always the same for clients. Here are 5 actionable tips to onboard your clients to new software tools and processes, so you can all get on the same page and deliver amazing work. Project managers spend a lot of time [...]
What These 15 Web Design Terms Mean – And Don’t MeanMarch 24, 2022
There are few groups who use more jargon than those tackling web design. Design terminology especially causes confusion on cross-disciplinary creative teams and full-service agencies, where not everyone speaks the same language. In order to design great websites, landing pages, product UX, and other digital experiences that are as usable as they are pleasing to [...]
7 Ways to Give & Get Better Creative Feedback [Punchlist Video Features]March 11, 2022
Sometimes it’s all in the ask. How you ask for feedback — whether it’s from a client, teammate, or stakeholder — can make all the difference on the quality of feedback you receive. Creating that ask is something that deserves your time and attention, as it impacts the relationship with the person delivering feedback, the [...]
Client Onboarding: 6 Ways to Create Lasting Client RelationshipsMarch 8, 2022
Client onboarding is a double-edged sword for agencies, studios, and freelancers. While your clients supply the work and pay the bills, they also require back-and-forth email conversations and time-intensive education on your work process that ultimately distract from the best part of your job — being creative. Fortunately, it doesn’t have to be this way. [...]
5 Tips for Better Client-Designer CommunicationSeptember 22, 2021
The client-designer relationship can be a breezy ride or a teeth-grinding journey. It all depends on how prepared you are to effectively communicate with your designer. Going in blind is a normal thing for clients to do when first looking for a designer. But starting the design process with a little preparation will go a [...]
Freelance Design Websites for Every ProjectSeptember 16, 2021
The freelance design world is hot with talent waiting for your project — you just have to know where to find it. We’ve marked out 10 platforms with freelance designers available for hire. Each one differs in price, client leg-work and expertise. So, jot out your priorities and see which fits your project best! Fiverr [...]
4 Things To Consider When Creating Your New WebsiteJanuary 4, 2021
They say your business website is like your virtual handshake – the first impression you will make on a potential client. With this in mind, it is vital that your website is seamless, easy to maneuver, and on brand. Whether you are building your website yourself, or you’ve reached out to an agency for support, [...]
Top 3 Tips When Providing Project Feedback To Your AgencyDecember 22, 2020
At Punchlist, communication is one of our top values. It’s the entire premise behind what we do! We believe communication lays the foundation for any business, project, or relationship in general. It’s a known fact that communication can get complicated when you don’t have the person right in front of you. We have all misread [...]
Your Pre-Launch Checklist!December 21, 2020
We all know the pressure that comes when it’s finally time to launch a website. With all the complexities, we can often catch ourselves thinking of all the things that could go wrong. No one wants to experience the frustration of grammatical errors or a failed capture form. That’s why we created our Pre-Launch essential [...]
Six Ways To Set Client BoundariesNovember 13, 2020
Just like all relationships, partnerships with clients require boundaries. We all want to strive to go above and beyond for our clients, but it is necessary that the line does not blur into something problematic. We see too often businesses being taken advantage of out of fear of upsetting or losing a client. Setting clear [...]
5 Best Practices When Communicating With ClientsOctober 1, 2020
We’ve all been there – you feel like you are running in circles with a client, and you’re at a loss for how you can better explain your thought process. The constant back and forth can take up tons of time, and create plenty of unnecessary frustration. Some misunderstandings can even lead to losing the [...]